Pediatrician John Snyder gives vaccine information to Tenzin Dekey, who had brought her 1-year-old son to Amherst Pediatrics for an annual exam. She accepted the vaccines that Snyder recommended.
Karen Brown/New England Public Media
hide caption
toggle caption
Karen Brown/New England Public Media
Dr. John Snyder, in Amherst, Mass., has been practicing pediatrics for 30 years. Whenever he wanted to find the most up-to-date research on treating young patients, he would turn to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
If he wanted to learn more about an outbreak of measles or hantavirus, he would pore over the weekly CDC report that came by email.
If a patient’s family was traveling to Africa or Asia, he would check the latest CDC vaccine recommendations for overseas travel.
And if family members at his practice in Amherst, Mass., expressed worries about potential side effects from a shot, he could always send them to the CDC’s website to bolster his argument to get the immunization.
Public trust in the CDC has hit bumps in the road during infectious disease outbreaks, but for medical professionals, Snyder said, “the CDC used to be, worldwide, the most trusted source of information pertaining to public health and infectious disease.”
Yet even doctors began losing trust, Snyder said, after Donald Trump was elected president again. Trump quickly tapped longtime anti-vaccine activist Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as his nominee to lead the Department of Health and Human Services, which oversees the CDC.
John Snyder is a pediatrician at Amherst Pediatrics in Amherst, Massachusetts.
Karen Brown/New England Public Media
hide caption
toggle caption
Karen Brown/New England Public Media
Within months of his confirmation as secretary, Kennedy had dismissed every member of the CDC’s vaccine advisory board and replaced them with new appointees, some of them prominent vaccine skeptics.
“It turned into a completely unreputable source of information,” Snyder said.
This rupture of scientific trust in the CDC has put many pediatricians like Snyder in a bind, as they no longer turn to the United States’ preeminent public health agency and instead search for ways to fill the information gap. Some doctors are launching their own vaccine education efforts, sometimes in collaboration with local public health departments.
On Jan. 5, the CDC removed some vaccines from the recommended vaccine schedule for all children — against the advice of major medical groups like the American Academy of Pediatrics.
The number of recommended vaccines shrank as the agency dropped vaccines for rotavirus, COVID-19, influenza, hepatitis A, hepatitis B and meningococcal disease from the list.
The agency did not respond to a request for comment for this story.
In March, after medical groups sued, a federal judge ordered the Trump administration to revert to the previous guidelines. The administration has appealed the judge’s decision.
A “shocking” thing to tell patients
The back-and-forth “creates a whole bunch of confusion in the public,” Snyder said. “And it’s very confusing even for healthcare providers.”
So he’s trying to be clear to patients about what the evidence shows, even if that means going against the federal government. His practice, Amherst Pediatrics, changed its website to say: “The CDC is no longer considered to be a reliable or legitimate source of information.”
“It’s shocking that we have to say that,” Snyder said. Instead, the site directs families to get information from their own doctor, the state of Massachusetts, or nongovernmental medical organizations including the AAP.
The independent health website Valley Vax is advertised on the sides of buses in Western Massachusetts.
Kiko Malin
hide caption
toggle caption
Kiko Malin
In the exam room, Snyder is having more tense conversations with families. He said some parents are explicit that they want to hew to what the CDC recommends. “Even if they don’t say that, we have definitely seen increasing hesitancy and questions,” he said. “All of that interferes with us protecting children.”
On a spring afternoon, several of Snyder’s young patients came into Amherst Pediatrics for routine visits.
“Let’s talk about vaccines,” Snyder said to one mother, Tenzin Dekey, who was there with her 1-year-old. Snyder explained that her son was due for the MMR vaccine, which protects against measles, mumps, and rubella, in addition to the chickenpox vaccine.
“So that’s four shots, two in each leg,” he said, as he handed Dekey CDC information sheets about the vaccines. She glanced at them and agreed to the shots.
Ironically, the information sheets are stamped with the CDC’s logo — as required by law — even though Amherst Pediatrics has explicitly directed patients away from the CDC. Snyder said he hates that disconnect.
“This has been a source of heated discussion,” he said. “How can we be saying, ‘Do not trust the CDC when it comes to vaccines,’ yet here is the information we’re giving our own patients when they’re in the office about vaccines?”
Another mother brought her 14-year-old son for his annual physical. She asked to be identified by only her first name, Melissa, so she could freely discuss her family’s private health issues.
The storeroom of childhood vaccines at Amherst Pediatrics.
Karen Brown/New England Public Media
hide caption
toggle caption
Karen Brown/New England Public Media
Snyder recommended the HPV vaccine, which helps prevent some cancers. Although Melissa had refused the HPV vaccine in a previous visit, this time she left the decision up to her son. He agreed to it. But for other vaccines, she wouldn’t budge.
“I’m a hard ‘no’ on the covid,” she told Snyder.
“We could talk about that if you want,” he suggested.
“I don’t need to talk about it,” she replied.
After the appointment, Melissa said she just doesn’t know whom to trust anymore when it comes to vaccine safety. She used to get information from the CDC but no longer does.
“I worry that it’s been politicized a lot, and I don’t like politics,” she said. “Now I prefer to hear things from people, healthcare professionals.”
Such distrust and confusion inspired Snyder to join an independent vaccine information campaign, along with other pediatric practices and health departments in the Connecticut River Valley of Western Massachusetts.
New coalition launches new website
The campaign’s website, which is promoted in Snyder’s waiting room, is called Valley Vax. It sidesteps the CDC and highlights advice from local doctors and national medical groups, including the AAP.
Valley Vax bought ads on the sides of buses in Western Massachusetts to promote the site, with the faces and testimonials of local doctors including Snyder.
“We wanted something that felt familiar and appealing and that they might be more likely to trust,” said Kiko Malin, director of Amherst’s public health department, who coordinates the Valley Vax effort.
She said the organizers decided not to criticize the CDC outright.
“Some information from the CDC is reasonable. Like they are doing a good job of tracking influenza-like illness rates in the country,” Malin said. “It’s important not to discount an organization completely.”
Still, she said it’s the first time she’s had to contradict health information from the CDC. “That’s not a comfortable place to be in at all,” she said.
Other health leaders are also banding together to get out evidence-based information. At the state level, California, Hawai’i, Oregon, and Washington — frustrated with the CDC — operate the West Coast Health Alliance to “ensure the public has access to credible information.” And governors of 14 states and Guam set up the Governors Public Health Alliance in response to declining trust in federal health agencies.
Locally, some public health departments are partnering with community leaders to reach people who have stopped listening to government institutions but “do have strong connections within their faith community or do have strong connections within their neighborhood,” said Adriane Casalotti, a spokesperson for the National Association of County and City Health Officials.
Like Amherst, many local health departments now direct people to professional medical organizations instead of the CDC, Casalotti said, because advice from those groups may change slightly as the science evolves, but it’s unlikely to change with each lawsuit against the government.
This story comes from NPR’s health reporting partnership with New England Public Media and KFF Health News.
